New York Supreme Court August 8, 2017 (People v. Ortega)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-08-2017

OPINION OF THE COURT

Daniel P. Conviser, J.

On March 29, 2013, the defendant was convicted after a jury trial presided over by this court of one count of rape in the first degree, one count of sexual abuse in the first degree and one count of rape in the third degree. He moves here to vacate that judgment pursuant to CPL 440.10 (1) (h) asserting that the court did not conduct a proper inquiry pursuant to Batson v Kentucky (476 US 79 [1986]) when defense counsel raised an objection to the “prosecutor’s exclusion of dark-complexioned male jurors.”1 Defendant’s argument is based on the recent decision of the New York Court of Appeals in People v Bridgeforth (28 NY3d 567 [2016]), which held that discrimination in jury selection based on skin color “as a classification separate from race” (or ethnicity) is a proper basis on which to raise a Batson challenge.2 The Bridgeforth decision was issued subsequent to the exhaustion of the defendant’s appeals in this case.

For the reasons set forth below the defendant’s motion is denied. This case also illustrates, however, the practical issues which are sure to recur as trial courts struggle with the question of how skin color, as distinct from race or ethnicity, should be assessed in Batson challenges. The rationale for the Bridge-forth decision is compelling. How trial courts will be able to practically assess whether a party is discriminating against jurors by virtue of “similar skin color, for example, dark-colored”3 is less clear.

Statement of Facts

The defendant’s conviction arises out of a sexual assault which occurred on November 5, 2010 in Manhattan. The evidence presented by the People indicated that the defendant approached the complainant on a Manhattan street at approximately 4:00 a.m. and that the complainant and defendant then agreed to spend time together and shared beers they went to purchase at a drug store. When the complainant reached the door of her building at approximately 5:30 a.m.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.