Massachusetts Appeals Court October 5, 2017, 16–P–1672 (Hri Servs., Inc. v. Simmons)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-10-2017
This is an appeal from a judgment entered on September 28, 2016, after a decision of the District Court Appellate Division, which reversed a portion of a prior judgment that resulted from the allowance of a motion for judgment at the close of the plaintiff's case, and remanded the matter for a hearing on damages. We vacate and remand.
Propriety of the appeal. The plaintiff brought suit in District Court against LSV, Inc. (LSV), for breach of contract, and against the defendant shareholders individually. Summary judgment was entered against LSV for breach of contract, and the case proceeded to trial against the shareholders on two theories-piercing the corporate veil and violation of G. L. c. 93A, § 11. During a bench trial, at the close of the plaintiff's case, the judge allowed the shareholders' motion pursuant to Mass.R.Civ.P. 41(b)(2), 365 Mass. 804 (1974), to dismiss the complaint. Judgment entered on December 21, 2011, as to all parties.3
The plaintiff appealed, arguing error in the dismissal of the c. 93A claim. The Appellate Division reversed, concluding that the shareholders' conduct constituted a knowing and willful violation of G. L. c. 93A, § 11.4 It then remanded the case for a hearing on damages. After the hearing on damages concluded, a final judgment entered on September 28, 2016, awarding the plaintiff c. 93A damages as against the shareholders. The shareholders did not appeal that judgment to the Appellate Division. Instead, their appeal was brought before this court.
The proper avenue would have been for the shareholders to appeal the September 28, 2016, judgment to the Appellate Division. See G. L. c. 231, § 108. However, "there are occasions on which we have exercised discretion to entertain an appeal even though it is not here as of right." Lombardi v. Lombardi, 68 Mass. App. Ct. 407, 410 (2007), and cases cited. The issues have been fully briefed on the merits.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit