Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit October 10, 2017, MDL Docket No. 1869; Miscellaneous No. 07–0489 (PLF) (In re Rail Freight Fuel Surcharge Antitrust Litig.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-10-2017
PAUL L. FRIEDMAN, United States District Judge
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PART ONE: INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND ...31
I. INTRODUCTION...31
II. BACKGROUND ...33
A. The Alleged Conspiracy ...35
B. Appeal to the D. C. Circuit ...38
C. Class Certification Papers and Supplemental Briefing Before the Class Certification Hearing ...39
D. Supplemental Expert Reports ...40
PART TWO: ADMISSIBILITY OF EXPERT TESTIMONY UNDER DAUBERT ...40
I. INTRODUCTION...40
II. EXPERT TESTIMONY AT CLASS CERTIFICATION ...41
A. Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence ...41
B. Daubert Test Versus Rule 22(b) Reliability Standard ...42
III. DAUBERT ANALYSIS OF THE EXPERTS IN THIS CASE ...43
A. Dr. Gordon Rausser ...43
1. Dr. Rausser's Credibility in Light of his Involvement with Cascade Settlement Services ...43
a. Factual Background Regarding Dr. Rausser and Cascade ...43
b. Court's Conclusions Regarding Dr. Rausser's Credibility in the Daubert Context....47
2. Rule 702 Analysis of Dr. Rausser's Expert Opinion....49
a. Introduction....49
b. Qualitative Economic Analysis ...50
c. Documentary Record and Defendants' Transaction Data as Evidence of Class-wide Impact....53
d. Common Factors Model ...54
e. Damages Model....56
f. Legacy Contracts ...59
B. Dr. Joseph P. Kalt ...63
1. Aggressiveness and Coverage of Fuel Surcharges ...64
a. Earning Power ...65
b. Coverage: Application, Negotiation, and Discounting of Fuel Surcharges ...66
2. False Positives ...67
a. Variable Fuel Coefficient ...67
b. Legacy False Positives....70
c. Rates Equal to Variable Costs ...70
d. Pre-Class Period Fuel Surcharges....71
3. Structural Break Analysis....72
4. Ordinary Fuel Cost Recovery ...74
5. Uninjured Class Members ...75
C. Dr. Jeffrey J. Leitzinger ...76
1. Dr. Rausser's Research Methodology, Analysis, and Model Design....77
2. Constant Fuel Coefficient: Margin Compression and Fuel Price Hedging ...78
3. Constant Fuel Coefficient: Box-Cox Sensitivity Analysis ...79
4. Annual Fuel Shares....80 *31D. Dr. Dennis W. Carlton .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit