District Court, Virgin Islands August 28, 2017, D.C. Civil App. No. 2006-88 (Archer v. Caribbean Auto Mart, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-08-2017
MEMORANDUM OPINION
(August 28, 2017)
Paul Archer appeals the order of the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands granting summary judgment against him and in favor of Caribbean Auto Mart, Inc. For the reasons stated herein, we affirm the lower court’s judgment.
*1026I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In or about October of 2002, Dothlyn Davis (“Davis”) submitted a complaint to the appellee, Caribbean Auto Mart, Inc. (“CAM”), about one of its then-employees, the appellant Paul Archer (“Archer”). Davis claimed that she had gone to CAM’s car dealership in St. Thomas seeking to purchase a used SUV. At the CAM car dealership, she was assisted by Archer. (J.A. at 4, 35-36.)
Despite Archer’s assistance, Davis found no car in CAM’S inventory that she liked. Davis claims that at this point Archer told her he could put her in touch with another CAM employee who was interested in trading a used SUV. Davis agreed to this arrangement. Shortly thereafter, Davis was contacted by an individual who identified himself as Elroy Carey (“Carey”), and who claimed to be a CAM employee.1 After several exchanges, Davis ultimately agreed to purchase a car in Florida for $8,200, which Carey would arrange to have transported to St. Thomas. Davis gave the $8,200 to Carey, although at the time she believed she was purchasing the car from CAM. (J.A. 36-44.)
When Davis received the car, it was a different color and a different model than Carey had promised. It also had serious mechanical problems and other issues. Davis attempted to get a refund of the purchase price from Archer, to no avail. Archer did, however, offer to resell the car. Specifically, he told Davis that if she parked the car near the CAM dealership, he would show it to potential CAM customers. (J.A. 44, 52-59.)
The car went unsold, and Davis received no refund, for several months. In or about October of 2002, the transmission in the car broke down and the car became inoperable.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit