District Court, D. Delaware March 30, 2017, Bankr. Case No. 08-13031-MFW; Adv. Pro. No. 10-55543-MFW; Civ. No. 16-252-LPS (Burtch v. Prudential Real Estate & Relocation Services, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-2017

MEMORANDUM

HONORABLE LEONARD P. STARK, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Pending before the Court is the Prudential1 Appellants’ appeal (D.I. 1) from the Bankruptcy Court’s Opinion and Order, Burtch v. Prudential Real Estate and Relocation Servs., Inc., et al. (In re AE Liquidation, Inc.), 2016 WL 1238848 (Bankr. D. Del. Mar. 29, 2016) (“Remand Order”), For the reasons that follow, the Court will affirm the Remand Order.

I. BACKGROUND

Eclipse Aviation Corporation (“Eclipse”), a manufacturer of private jets, engaged Prudential to provide relocation benefits to its employees under a Relocation Services Agreement. On November *10625, 2008 (“Petition Date”), Eclipse filed its voluntary petition for relief under chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code. On March 5, 2009, the case was converted to chapter 7, and Trustee was appointed. In November of 2010, Trustee filed a complaint against Prudential asserting that twelve transfers made by Eclipse to Prudential within the ninety days preceding the Petition Date (“Preference Period”), totaling $781,702.61, were preferential and avoidable under § 547(b) of the Bankruptcy Code. Prudential asserted affirmative defenses under the Bankruptcy Code, including § 547(c)(2)’s ordinary course defense,2 and § 547(c)(4)’s new value defense.3

In March of 2013, the Bankruptcy Court held a two-day trial in the adversary proceeding. The parties agreed that Prudential had a new value defense but disputed the amount. Trustee conceded new value totaling $56,057,42, while Prudential asserted $128,379.40 of new value was provided to Eclipse following the Petition Date. Prudential’s Director of Accounting, Ms. Williams-Varner, prepared a chart setting forth the services rendered to Eclipse after September 2, 2008 (the date of first Preference Period transfer) and the corresponding invoices. (See 3/12/13 Tr. at 101) Trustee argued that 21 invoices dated March 5, 2009, in total amount of $71,808.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.