Supreme Court of The Virgin Islands January 20, 2017, S. Ct. Criminal No. 2014-0032 (Pickering v. People)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-01-2017

OPINION OF THE COURT

(January 20, 2017)

CABRET, Associate Justice.

Kelvin Pickering appeals his convictions on two counts of second-degree unlawful sexual contact, arguing that his convictions must be vacated because the Superior Court removed a juror during deliberations without first finding good cause to do so. For the reasons that follow, we vacate Pickering’s convictions and remand for a new trial.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

In August 2012, the Virgin Islands Department of Housing, Parks, and Recreation1 (“DHPR”) held a beach party at Lindbergh Bay, St. Thomas, for two of its summer camps: the cultural camp and the baseball camp. At the time, Pickering was a 32-year-old senior counselor for the baseball camp, and K.S. was a 15-year-old junior counselor for the cultural camp. Shortly before lunch, several counselors saw Pickering and K.S. in the water together past the buoys that marked the boundary set for the campers because of the depth of the water. Pickering and K.S. were facing each other in the water, Pickering appeared to be holding K.S. up and had his hands under the water, and K.S.’s arms were around his neck. Christina Miller, the cultural camp leader, noticed that they were too far out in the water beyond the buoys and asked two counselors to check on *281them. Miller reported this incident to DHPR director Derek Heyliger later that day, who contacted K.S.’s mother.

Three days later, K.S. and her mother met with Miller, Pickering, and Heyliger to discuss the incident. Speaking to Miller alone, K.S. said that Pickering forced her into the water, dragged her past the buoys, placed her legs around his waist, and her arms around his neck. K.S. said Pickering then inserted his fingers into her vagina, attempted to insert his penis into her vagina, and placed her hand on his penis. After K.S. described the incident to Miller, Miller told Heyliger and K.S.’s mother. K.S.’s mother informed the police of the incident and took K.S. to Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.