Supreme Court of Georgia February 19, 2018, S17A1419 (Kennedy v. Kohnle)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-2018

303 Ga. 95

FINAL COPY

S17A1419. KENNEDY v. KOHNLE.

PETERSON, Justice.

This case raises a question regarding the retroactive application of

Alexander v. State, 297 Ga. 59 (772 SE2d 655) (2015), in which we held that

an attorney’s failure to counsel his client about parole eligibility may give rise

to a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel. Teresa Lynn Kohnle pleaded

guilty to felony murder in December 2010, before we decided Alexander but

after the United States Supreme Court issued its opinion in Padilla v. Kentucky,

559 U. S. 356 (130 SCt 1473, 176 LE2d 284) (2010), on which we relied in

deciding Alexander. Sentenced to life in prison, Kohnle filed a petition for a writ

of habeas corpus, alleging that her plea counsel was ineffective in several ways,

including that he failed to inform her of the parole eligibility implications of a

life sentence. The habeas court granted Kohnle’s petition, relying on Alexander

to conclude that Kohnle’s counsel had rendered ineffective assistance. The

Warden appeals, arguing that the habeas court erred in applying Alexander

retroactively. We agree with the Warden that the habeas court erred by applying

Alexander to find that plea counsel performed deficiently by failing to advise

Kohnle that she would not be eligible for parole for 30 years if she pleaded

guilty, and thus we vacate the habeas court’s order. But we remand for the

habeas court to consider Kohnle’s claim that counsel was deficient for

affirmatively misinforming her about parole eligibility matters, something we

had held could support a claim of ineffective assistance long before Kohnle

entered her plea. See Smith v. Williams, 277 Ga. 778, 778-779 (1) (596 SE2d

112) (2004).

1. Factual background

Kohnle was indicted in August 2008 for malice murder, felony murder,

and two counts of first degree arson in connection with the June 2007 death of

her husband in a house fire.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.