New Mexico Supreme Court March 1, 2018, S-1-SC-35641 (Garcia v. Hatch Valley Pub. Schs.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-2018

1 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO

2 Opinion Number: ________________

3 Filing Date: March 1, 2018

4 NO. S-1-SC-35641

5 NATALIE F. GARCIA,

6 Plaintiff-Respondent,

7 v.

8 HATCH VALLEY PUBLIC SCHOOLS,

9 Defendant-Petitioner.

10 ORIGINAL PROCEEDING ON CERTIORARI

11 Douglas R. Driggers, District Judge

12 German Burnette & Associates, LLC

13 Ethan Watson

14 Elizabeth L. German

15 Albuquerque, NM

16 for Petitioner

17 John P. Mobbs

18 El Paso, TX

19 Law Firm of Daniela Labinoti, P.C.

20 Daniela Labinoti

21 El Paso, TX

1 for Respondent

1 OPINION

2 MAES, Justice.

3 {1} Plaintiff Natalie Garcia, née Watkins, sued her former employer, Defendant

4 Hatch Valley Public Schools (HVPS), for employment discrimination under the New

5 Mexico Human Rights Act (NMHRA), NMSA 1978, § 28-1-7(A), (I) (2004).

6 Plaintiff alleged that HVPS terminated her employment as a school bus driver based

7 on her national origin, which she described as “German” and “NOT Hispanic.”

8 HVPS successfully moved for summary judgment in the district court, and the Court

9 of Appeals reversed, focusing on Plaintiff’s “primary contention” that HVPS had

10 discriminated against her and terminated her employment because she is not Hispanic.

11 Garcia v. Hatch Valley Pub. Schs., 2016-NMCA-034, ¶¶ 11, 48, 369 P.3d 1.

12 {2} We granted certiorari under Rule 12-502 NMRA and reverse the Court of

13 Appeals. We hold that summary judgment in HVPS’s favor was appropriate because

14 Plaintiff failed to establish a prima facie case of discrimination and failed to raise a

15 genuine issue of material fact about whether HVPS’s asserted reason for terminating

16 her employment was pretextual.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.