Appellate Court of Illinois March 2, 2018, 3-17-0087 (Palm v. Holocker)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-2018

Digitally signed by

Reporter of Decisions

Reason: I attest to the

Illinois Official Reports accuracy and

integrity of this

document

Appellate Court Date: 2018.02.20

17:26:54 -06'00'

Palm v. Holocker, 2017 IL App (3d) 170087

Appellate Court SCARLETT PALM, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. RUBEN HOLOCKER,

Caption Defendant (Karl Bayer, Contemnor-Appellant).

District & No. Third District

Docket No. 3-17-0087

Filed December 11, 2017

Decision Under Appeal from the Circuit Court of Marshall County, No. 16-L-5; the

Review Hon. Thomas A. Keith, Judge, presiding.

Judgment Reversed in part and vacated in part; cause remanded.

Counsel on Daniel E. Compton and Karl E. Bayer, of Compton Law Group, of

Appeal Elgin, for appellant.

Philip M. O’Donnell and Christopher H. Sokn, of Kingery Durree &

O’Donnell, Associates, of Peoria, for appellee.

Panel JUSTICE SCHMIDT delivered the judgment of the court, with

opinion.

Justices O’Brien and Wright concurred with the judgment and

opinion.

OPINION

¶1 Scarlett Palm filed a personal injury lawsuit against Ruben Holocker on June 22, 2016.

Contemnor, Karl Bayer, represented Holocker. Contemnor invited civil contempt to

challenge the circuit court’s discovery order that compelled Holocker to answer written

discovery. He argues that Holocker’s statutory physician-patient privilege (735 ILCS 5/8-802

(West 2016)) protects his private medical information from discovery unless he affirmatively

places his physical or mental health at issue. Palm counters that the physician-patient

privilege does not apply in civil cases where the defendant’s physical or mental health is

relevant to the case; the statute does not require the defendant-patient to affirmatively place

his or her health at issue. We agree with contemnor. We reverse the circuit court’s discovery

order and vacate its contempt order.

¶2 BACKGROUND

¶3 Palm’s complaint alleged that on October 18, 2014, Holocker struck Palm, a pedestrian,

with his vehicle at a crosswalk in Lacon.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.