Superior Court of Pennsylvania May 4, 2018, 152 WDA 2017 (Hoffman, R. v. Gongaware, S.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-05-2018

J-S75007-17

2018 PA Super 116

RANDY E. HOFFMAN AND SHERRY L. : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF

HOFFMAN, HIS WIFE : PENNSYLVANIA

:

Appellants :

:

:

v. :

:

: No. 152 WDA 2017

SCOTT A. GONGAWARE AND KERN :

BROTHERS LUMBER COMPANY, :

A/K/A KERN BROTHERS LUMBER :

COMPANY, INC. :

Appeal from the Order January 10, 2017

In the Court of Common Pleas of Somerset County Civil Division at

No(s): No. 503 Civil 2014

BEFORE: SHOGAN, J., OTT, J., and MUSMANNO, J.

OPINION BY SHOGAN, J.: FILED MAY 4, 2018

Randy E. Hoffman and Sherry L. Hoffman (“Appellants”) appeal from the

trial court’s January 10, 2017 order sustaining the preliminary objections in

the nature of a demurrer of Scott A. Gongaware and Kern Brothers Lumber

Company (“Appellees”) and dismissing Appellants’ complaint. On appeal,

Appellants argue that the trial court erred in concluding that their reservation

of timber rights in a duly recorded deed constituted an interest in personal

property, rather than land, and in finding that they forfeited this interest when

they failed to remove the timber in a reasonable amount of time. After careful

review, we reverse and remand for further proceedings.

The trial court summarized the facts as follows:

[Appellants], Randy E. Hoffman and Sherry L. Hoffman,

husband-and-wife, were the owners of a 20 acre parcel of land

J-S75007-17

on which a crop of timber existed in Lincoln Township, Somerset

County, together with a residence in which the [Appellants]

apparently resided. On October 12, 1977 [Appellants] conveyed

the premises to Consolidation Coal Company by deed recorded in

record book volume 812, page 646 and recorded on the following

day [(“the 1977 Deed”)]. Of particular importance are the various

“Exceptions and Reservations” which we shall include verbatim.

EXCEPTING AND RESERVING all coal and mining

rights previously conveyed by predecessors in title.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.