California Supreme Court June 25, 2018, S240918 (Samara v. Matar)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-06-2018

Filed 6/25/18

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CALIFORNIA

RANA SAMARA, )

)

Plaintiff and Appellant, )

) S240918

v. )

) Ct.App. 2/7 B265752

HAITHAM MATAR, )

) Los Angeles County

Defendant and Respondent. ) Super. Ct. No. EC056720

____________________________________)

When a trial court judgment rests on more than one ground, it may be

impossible for a losing party to obtain appellate review of all of the court’s

determinations. In a breach of contract action, for example, a trial court might

grant a defense motion for summary judgment because no contract was formed,

and because in any event there was no breach. On direct review, an appellate

court could affirm if either of those conclusions was correct, without resolving or

even considering the other one. Thus, a plaintiff who argues on appeal that there

was a contract (and that the contract was breached) might lose based on a lack of

breach without appellate review of whether a contract existed in the first place.

This case concerns the claim- and issue-preclusive significance, in future

litigation, of a conclusion relied on by the trial court and challenged on appeal, but

not addressed by the appellate court. We hold that the preclusive effect of the

judgment should be evaluated as though the trial court had not relied on the

1

unreviewed ground. Our contrary decision in People v. Skidmore (1865) 27

Cal. 287 (Skidmore) is overruled.

I. BACKGROUND

A. Claim and Issue Preclusion

The law of preclusion helps to ensure that a dispute resolved in one case is

not relitigated in a later case. Although the doctrine has ancient roots (see Note,

Developments in the Law: Res Judicata (1952) 65 Harv. L.Rev. 818, 820-822), its

contours and associated terminology have evolved over time. We now refer to

“claim preclusion” rather than “res judicata” (Mycogen Corp. v. Monsanto Co.

(2002) 28 Cal.4th 888, 896-897 (Mycogen)), and use “issue preclusion” in place of

“direct or collateral estoppel” (Migra v. Warren City School Dist. Bd. of Educ.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.