Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals June 27, 2018, ASBCA No. 59809 (Relyant, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-2018

ARMED SERVICES BOARD OF CONTRACT APPEALS

Appeal of -- )

)

Relyant, LLC ) ASBCA No. 59809

)

Under Contract No. W91B4N-08-D-0011 )

APPEARANCE FOR THE APPELLANT: James H. Price, Esq.

Lacy, Price & Wagner, PC

Knoxville, TN

APPEARANCES FOR THE GOVERNMENT: Raymond M. Saunders, Esq.

Army Chief Trial Attorney

MAJ Jason W. Allen, JA

Trial Attorney

OPINION BY ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE PROUTY

The dispute before us, 1 which was aired in a three-day hearing, is centered upon

the government's acceptance of certain pre-fabricated relocatable buildings (RLBs) for

use at two different sites in Afghanistan. As will be described in far greater detail

below, different government contracting officer representatives (CORs) at the two

different locations had diverging views regarding whether the RLBs initially provided

by appellant, Relyant, LLC (Relyant), should be permitted under the contract

specifications that applied to both locations. In particular, the RLBs delivered to the

first site passed a First Article Test (FAT) at that site, but were deemed to be out of

compliance with the contract's statement of work (SOW) by the contracting officer

(CO), and were not permitted at the second site. To get around the problem, Relyant

shipped the RLB components first delivered to second site to the first site, where the

local accepting authority (not the CO) apparently turned a blind eye to the RLBs'

failure to comply with the SOW2 ; Relyant then revamped its means of manufacturing

the RLBs to provide RLB components that satisfied the CO (and contract) at the

second site. Yet, despite the equities of the matter superficially weighing in favor of

Relyant for having had some units accepted, we find that we cannot grant it the relief

1

We granted summary judgment in favor of the government in the related appeal of

ASBCA No. 58172. See Relyant, LLC, ASBCA No. 58172, 16-1 BCA ,r 36,228,

aff'd, 683 F. App'x 960 (Fed. Cir. 2017).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.