Court of Appeals of Washington July 16, 2018, 76825-5 (Joel Zellmer v. King County)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-2018

FILED

COURT OF APPEALS DIV I 1. .f%

STATE OF WASHINGTON t1Tr:

1018 JUL 16 AK 9:20

THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DIVISION ONE

JOEL ZELLMER, )

) No. 76825-5-1

Appellant )

) DIVISION ONE

v. )

)

KING COUNTY, ) UNPUBLISHED OPINION

)

Respondent. )

) FILED: July 16, 2018

SPEARMAN, J. —Washington's Public Records Act(PRA)chapter 42.56 RCW

requires agencies to respond to a public records request by conducting a reasonable

search and providing all identifiable records. Prison inmate Joel Zellmer submitted two

public records requests to the King County Prosecuting Attorney's Office(KCPAO)

asking for photographs of the inside of his home that were taken on two specific dates.

Zellmer argued that King County violated the PRA and acted in bad faith by failing to

produce 235 digital photographs of the inside of his home until after his lawsuit was

filed. The trial court dismissed the lawsuit. Because the KCPAO used an unreliable

method for determining the date on which the photographs were taken, we conclude

that the search was inadequate. However, because the undisputed record establishes

that the agency did not act in bad faith, we conclude that Zellmer is not entitled to an

award of penalties and affirm the dismissal.

No. 76825-5-1/2

FACTS

Zellmer has been an inmate at the Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla

since 2010. The KCPAO's public records unit is comprised of a public records officer,

Kristie Johnson, a public records paralegal, Myralynn Nitura, and a public records

specialist, Meghan Moore. The KCPAO stores 59 banker's boxes of records relating to

Zellmer's criminal case. Of these, 54 boxes are kept in the King County Courthouse and

another five boxes are kept in the Appellate Unit in the King County Administration

Building. Since his conviction, Zellmer has made 24 separate public records requests to

the KCPAO.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.