Court of Appeals of Tennessee July 17, 2018, E2017-01501-COA-R3-CV (Gerald Largen v. The City Of Harriman)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-07-2018

07/17/2018

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

AT KNOXVILLE

March 13, 2018 Session

GERALD LARGEN v. THE CITY OF HARRIMAN

Appeal from the Circuit Court for Roane County

No. 2014-CV-173 Michael S. Pemberton, Judge

No. E2017-01501-COA-R3-CV

This case involves a claim brought by a landowner challenging the validity of certain

annexation ordinances that incorporated his property into the City of Harriman (the

“City”). In December 2014, the landowner filed a declaratory judgment action against

the City in the Roane County Circuit Court (“trial court”), alleging that several 1959

annexation ordinances passed by the City were void ab initio because a river adjacent to

the City prevented land on the opposite side of the river from being contiguous with the

City’s original boundaries. The landowner alleged that as a result of the first

annexation’s purported invalidity, all subsequent annexations based on contiguity with

the lands annexed in the 1959 ordinances were void by extension. The landowner sought

a judgment voiding the challenged annexation ordinances, recovery of the real estate

taxes he had paid to the City for his real property included in the annexed land, and a

permanent injunction preventing the City from imposing any charges or taxes against

him. The City responded with a motion to dismiss pursuant to Tennessee Rule of Civil

Procedure 12.02, arguing that the landowner’s sole remedy would have been an action in

the nature of a quo warranto proceeding pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated § 6-51-

103 (2015). In the alternative, the City argued that dismissal was proper because the

landowner had not joined necessary parties who would be affected by the judgment he

sought. Determining that other landowners with title to real property inside the annexed

areas in question were indispensable to the landowner’s claim, the trial court denied the

motion to dismiss and directed the landowner to join the necessary parties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.