Supreme Court of Pennsylvania July 30, 2018, 166 Disciplinary Rules (In Re: Amendment of Rule 7.3 of Pa Rules of Professional Conduct)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-07-2018
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN RE: : NO. 166
:
ORDER AMENDING RULE OF : DISCIPLINARY BOARD
PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT 7.3 :
:
:
:
DISSENTING STATEMENT
JUSTICE DONOHUE
I respectfully disagree with the decision of the majority of my colleagues to
adopt the proposed amendment to Rule of Professional Conduct 7.3. Under both the
United States and Pennsylvania Constitutions, commercial speech that is neither
misleading nor related to unlawful activity may be regulated only if, inter alia, the
commercial speech regulation is narrowly drawn. Florida Bar v. Went For It, Inc., 515
U.S. 618, 624 (1995) (citing Central Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp. v. Public Serv. Comm’n
of N.Y., 447 U.S. 557, 564-65 (1980)); Commonwealth Bureau of Prof. and
Occupational Aff. v. State Bd. of Physical Therapy, 728 A.2d 340, 343 (Pa. 1999).
This Court has held that this requires commercial speech regulations to be the least
restrictive means of advancing the asserted interest. Commonwealth Bureau of Prof.
and Occupational Aff., 728 A.2d at 343.
As proposed, the rule appears to be wildly over inclusive and will curb more
speech than is necessary to effectuate the goal of the amendment. The proposed
amendment does not differentiate between the vast majority of domestic relations
actions and those where there exists the potential that a partner may become violent
when learning of the domestic relations action. In my view, there is a less restrictive
alternative available, as the Court could require that in cases where domestic violence
is a concern, the plaintiff could file a motion to seal the complaint until service upon the
defendant is made. It seems to me that such a rule would accomplish the laudable
goal of the amendment – reducing domestic violence – while also ensuring that it does
not unconstitutionally infringe upon an attorney’s right to commercial speech.
As the proposed amendment does not pass constitutional scrutiny, I dissent.
-2-
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit