Supreme Court of Pennsylvania August 21, 2018, 45 WM 2017 (In Re: 40th Statewide IGJ)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-08-2018

[J-40-2018] [MO: Saylor, C.J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

WESTERN DISTRICT

IN RE: FORTIETH STATEWIDE : No. 45 WM 2017

INVESTIGATING GRAND JURY :

:

: Appeal from the Order of the

PETITION OF: DIOCESE OF : Supervising Judge of the Fortieth

HARRISBURG AND DIOCESE OF : Statewide Investigating Grand Jury

GREENSBURG : entered on 6/15/17 at Allegheny

: County No. CP-02-MD-0000571-2016

:

ARGUED: May 15, 2018

CONCURRING OPINION

JUSTICE BAER DECIDED: AUGUST 21, 2018

I join the erudite Majority Opinion. I write only to voice my concern with one aspect

of its expression. Atypically, the Majority twice invokes this Court’s “supervisory authority”

to mandate substantive modifications to the entry of appearance form under scrutiny. We

do not often invoke our superintendence of the judiciary as justification for a sua sponte

form change, and I have no recollection of the Court ever employing this precept to alter

a form (or rule) within an opinion. Rather, our normal protocol is to refer the underlying

issue to the appropriate committee and permit it to consider adjustments through its

customary process. Notably, in this regard, we presently have an ad hoc committee

reviewing all aspects of Pennsylvania’s grand jury practice.

Be this as it may, I can abide by the Majority’s invocation of our supervisory

authority and employment thereof in an opinion to alter the subject entry of appearance

form in two substantive aspects so long as it is understood that the use of this

methodology does not alter the inherent ability of our various committees, including the

ad hoc grand jury study group, to modify the form as statutory changes, caselaw, or other

superseding factors would require. While the Majority does not say this, it does not

suggest anything to the contrary.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.