United States Court of International Trade September 17, 2018, Consol. 13-00288 (CP Kelco US, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-2018

Consol. Court No. 13-00288 Page 2

Gum from the People’s Republic of China, 78 Fed. Reg. 33,351 (Dep’t Commerce June 4, 2013)

(final determ.) (“Final Determination”) and accompanying Issues & Decision Mem. (“I&D

Mem.”), amended by Xanthan Gum from the People’s Republic of China, 78 Fed. Reg. 43,143

(Dep’t Commerce July 19, 2013) (am. final determ.). The four prior opinions of this court

thoroughly set forth the facts underlying this appeal. CP Kelco US, Inc. v. United States, Slip

Op. 15-27, 2015 WL 1544714 (CIT Mar. 31, 2015) (“CP Kelco I”); CP Kelco US, Inc. v. United

States, Slip Op. 16-36, 2016 WL 1403657 (CIT Apr. 8, 2016) (“CP Kelco II”); CP Kelco US,

Inc. v. United States, 41 CIT __, 211 F. Supp. 3d 1338 (2017) (“CP Kelco III”); CP Kelco US,

Inc. v. United States, Slip Op. 18-36, 2018 WL 1703143 (CIT Apr. 5, 2018) (“CP Kelco IV”).

The court presumes familiarity with those opinions. For the reasons discussed below, the court

sustains Commerce’s Remand Results.

BACKGROUND

In its Final Determination, Commerce concluded that the Thai Ajinomoto financial

statements constituted a better source for calculating surrogate financial ratios than the Thai

Fermentation financial statements. I&D Mem. at cmt. 2. Commerce first disregarded the Thai

Fermentation statements on the basis that the record did not contain a full English translation,

without making a finding that the untranslated portions were crucial to Commerce’s calculations.

Id. Commerce then selected the only remaining statements, those of Thai Ajinomoto, despite the

fact that the Thai Ajinomoto statements “show evidence of the receipt of countervailable

subsidies.” Id. Defendant-Intervenors Neimenggu Fufeng Biotechnologies, Co., Ltd. and

Shandong Fufeng Fermentation Co., Ltd. (collectively, “Fufeng”) challenged this determination,

arguing that Commerce failed to properly justify its disregard of the Thai Fermentation

statements. Def.-Intervenor Rule 56.2 Mot. for J. on the Agency R. 13–22, ECF No. 28 (Mar.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.