Nevada Supreme Court October 4, 2018, 72685 (HOWARD VS. HUGHES)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-2018

combined-opinion

134 Nev., Advance Opinion 130

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

ELIZABETH C. HOWARD, AN No. 72

INDIVIDUAL,

Appellant,

vs. OCT 0 4 2018

SHAUGHNAN L. HUGHES,

Respondent.

Appeal from a district court order in an action to partition real

property. Tenth Judicial District Court, Churchill County; Thomas L.

Stockard, Judge.

Affirmed.

Kozak & Associates, LLC, and Charles R. Kozak, Reno,

for Appellant.

Allison MacKenzie, Ltd., and Justin M. Townsend, Carson City,

for Respondent.

BEFORE PICKERING, GIBBONS and HARDESTY, JJ.

OPINION

By the Court, GIBBONS, J.:

In this proceeding, we are asked to clarify the property interest

presumptions outlined in Sack v. Tomlin, 110 Nev. 204,871 P.2d 298 (1994),

and Langevin v. York, 111 Nev. 1481, 907 P.2d 981 (1995). Under Sack,

cotenants are presumed to equally share property, "unless circumstances

indicate otherwise." Sack, 110 Nev. at 213, 871 P.2d at 304. Additionally,

the presumption of equal shares may be rebutted through unequal

contributions to property by unrelated cotenants who lack donative intent.

Id. If successfully rebutted, fractional shares are based on the amount

contributed by each party. Id. Langevin purportedly applied the Sack

presumptions to joint tenants, but it divided property in proportion to the

amount contributed by each party without clearly rebutting the

presumption of equal ownership. Langevin, 111 Nev. at 1485-86, 907 P.2d

at 984. We take this opportunity to clarify that the presumptions from Sack

concerning tenants in common apply to joint tenants. As such, prior to

dividing fractional shares held by cotenants, the initial presumption of

equal ownership must be successfully rebutted. We therefore hold that

because Hughes rebutted the secondary presumption by presenting

substantial evidence of Howard's donative intent, Howard and Hughes were

joint tenants with equal ownership interests in the property. Accordingly,

we affirm the decision of the district court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.