Supreme Court of Colorado October 15, 2018, 16S721, Ybarra (Ybarra v. Greenberg & Sada, P.C.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-2018

Opinions of the Colorado Supreme Court are available to the

public and can be accessed through the Judicial Branch’s homepage at

http://www.courts.state.co.us. Opinions are also posted on the

Colorado Bar Association’s homepage at http://www.cobar.org.

ADVANCE SHEET HEADNOTE

October 15, 2018

2018 CO 81

No. 16S721, Ybarra v. Greenberg & Sada, P.C.—Finance, Banking, and Credit—

Insurance—Statutory Interpretation—Torts.

Ybarra petitioned for review of the court of appeals’ judgment affirming the

dismissal of her Colorado Fair Debt Collection Practices Act action against Greenberg &

Sada. The district court dismissed for failure to state a claim, finding that damages arising

from a subrogated tort claim do not qualify as a debt within the contemplation of the Act.

The court of appeals agreed, reasoning that the undefined term “transaction” in the Act’s

definition of “Debt,” required some kind of business dealing, as distinguished from the

commission of a tort; and to the extent an insurance contract providing for the

subrogation of the rights of an insured constitutes a transaction in and of itself, that

transaction is not one obligating the debtor to pay money, as required by the Act.

The supreme court holds that because a tort does not obligate the tortfeasor to pay

damages, a tort cannot be a transaction giving rise to an obligation to pay money, and is

therefore not a debt within contemplation of the Act; and because an insurance contract

providing for the subrogation of the rights of a damaged insured is not a transaction

giving rise to an obligation of the tortfeasor to pay money, it also cannot constitute a

transaction creating a debt within contemplation of the Act. Accordingly, the judgment

of the court of appeals is affirmed.

The Supreme Court of the State of Colorado

2 East 14th Avenue • Denver, Colorado 80203

2018 CO 81

Supreme Court Case No. 16SC721

Certiorari to the Colorado Court of Appeals

Court of Appeals Case No. 15CA485

Petitioner:

Francis Ybarra,

v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.