Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York December 3, 2018, 2018 NYSlipOp 51724(U) (58 Elizabeth NY, LLC v. Ho Wou Bake Shoppe, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-2018

58 Elizabeth NY, LLC, Petitioner-Landlord-Appellant, against Ho Wou Bake Shoppe, Inc., Kuey Wing Lee and Warren Lee, Respondents-Tenants-Respondents, and "XYZ Corp.," Respondent-Undertenant. Landlord appeals from a final judgment of the Civil Court of the City of New York, New York County (Joan M. Kenney, J.), entered on or about December 4, 2017, after a hearing, which dismissed the petition in a holdover summary proceeding. Per Curiam. Final judgment (Joan M. Kenney, J.), entered on or about December 4, 2017, reversed, with $25 costs, petition reinstated, and matter remanded for further proceedings consistent herewith. The hearing evidence, fairly interpreted, supports the court's determination that respondents proved, by clear and convincing evidence, that the present lease agreement between the former owner/landlord and two of the respondents, commencing January 1, 2016, did not accurately express the parties' intentions and that, as a result of mutual mistake, the agreement failed to include the "basement" space in the description of the demised commercial premises (see Chimart Assoc. v Paul, 66 NY2d 570, 573 [1986]; 313-315 W. 125th St. L.L.C. v Arch Specialty Ins. Co., 138 AD3d 601, 602 [2016]). The unequivocal testimony of the corporate respondent's principal and the principals of the prior owner - who drafted and executed the subject lease without the benefit of legal counsel - showed that for more than 20 years the basement had "always" been included in the leases, but that, due to an "oversight," the term "basement" was mistakenly omitted from the most recent lease. Given the parties' course of performance, which is "the most persuasive evidence of the agreed intention of the parties" (Warberg Opportunistic Trading Fund L.P. v GeoResources, Inc., 151 AD3d 465, 471 [2017]), we agree with Civil Court that the lease agreement contained a mutual mistake.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.