Supreme Court of Virginia December 6, 2018, Record 180162 (Gordon v. Kiser)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-12-2018

PRESENT: Lemons, C.J., Goodwyn, Mims, Powell, Kelsey, McCullough, JJ., and Lacy, S.JJ.

CARL D. GORDON

OPINION BY

v. Record No. 180162 SENIOR JUSTICE ELIZABETH B. LACY

December 6, 2018

JEFFREY B. KISER, ET AL.

FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF WISE COUNTY

Chadwick S. Dotson, Judge

In this appeal we consider whether the circuit court erred in denying a motion for nonsuit,

prospectively denying an inmate in forma pauperis status pursuant to Code § 8.01-692, and

imposing a pre-service review with possible summary dismissal on the inmate’s future filings.

FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS

Carl D. Gordon, an inmate at Red Onion State Prison, filed a complaint seeking

injunctive relief to protect him from alleged unsanitary dental treatment by the prison’s dental

assistant. The circuit court granted Gordon in forma pauperis status on September 8, 2017. A

summons and copy of the complaint were sent to the defendants, Prison Warden Jeffrey B. Kiser,

Assistant Warden J. Artrip, and N. H. Scott, Deputy Director of Administration, Virginia

Department of Corrections (collectively “the Warden”) and a hearing was set for November 1,

2017.

On October 10, 2017, the Warden filed a demurrer, plea of sovereign immunity and

motion to dismiss. In addition to asserting that the Warden was entitled to sovereign immunity,

the Warden argued that Gordon’s complaint failed to state a claim upon which relief could be

granted, and that, in dismissing the complaint, the circuit court should include “an express

finding” that the dismissal counted as a “strike” for purposes of Code § 8.01-692, which denies

in forma pauperis status to prisoners who have had at least three cases dismissed for being

frivolous, malicious or for failure to state a claim. The Warden also asked that the circuit court

order that any future complaint Gordon files be subject to pre-service review and possible

summary dismissal.

Gordon filed a motion for temporary injunction on October 17.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.