Washington Supreme Court December 6, 2018, 95603-1 (State v. Henderson)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-12-2018

®P»"'oh was filed for record

IN CLERM OFFICE \ at L...W 2.^(7

»S>RaECOUS?T,SlJaECF\®«XiKaTO|| — ■■■ WI. j<^l ^

I DATE DEC 0 §' 7Mii

-}rjAAk.uuki XA- —

"cHiEF JUSTICE 1 SUSAN L..CARLSON

/ SUPREME COURT CLERK

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Petitioner, No. 95603-1

V.

MICHAEL DAVID HENDERSON,

Filed DEC n 6 ?fl1«

Respondent.

GonzAlez,J.—It is generally not murder to kill another in self-defense. It

may not be murder—^though it is often a serious crime—^to kill another by accident.

Michael Henderson shot and killed Abubakar Abdi during an argument.

Henderson was charged with felony murder based on second degree assault with a

deadly weapon. Henderson contended that while acting in self-defense, he

accidentally killed Abdi. The jury was instructed on the defense ofjustifiable

homicide. The trial court did not instruct the jury on excusable homicide. Under

the instructions given, the jury necessarily found that the shooting was neither self-

defense nor accident when it found Henderson guilty offelony murder predicated

on second degree assault. The Court of Appeals reversed, finding the trial court

State V. Henderson, No. 95603-1

erred when it failed to give the excusable homicide instruction. We granted the

State's petition for review.

The State argues that the excusable homicide instruction was properly

rejected. We agree. Henderson was able to adequately argue his theory of the case

under the proper instructions that were given. We reverse the Court of Appeals

and remand back to that court for further proceedings under RAP 13.7(b).

Facts

On October 11, 2015, Henderson shot and killed 20-year-old Abdi. Abdi

and his friends were socializing at a restaurant and, later, at a Shell gas station

across the street. There, Abdi began arguing with Nekea Terrell. While Terrell

was buying alcohol at the gas station, Abdi called her names and told her to hurry

up. Terrell, Abdi, and Abdi's acquaintances continued to insult each other.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.