Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 28, 2018, 48 WAP 2017 (PA Independent Oil & Gas Assoc. v. PUC, Aplt.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-2018

[J-23A-2018 and J-23B-2018] [MO: Todd, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

WESTERN DISTRICT

SNYDER BROTHERS, INC., : No. 47 WAP 2017

:

Appellee : Appeal from the Order of the

: Commonwealth Court entered March

: 29, 2017 at No. 1043 CD 2015,

v. : reversing the Order of the Public Utility

: Commission entered June 11, 2015 at

: No. C-2014-2402746.

PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY :

COMMISSION, : ARGUED: April 11, 2018

:

Appellant :

PENNSYLVANIA INDEPENDENT OIL & : No. 48 WAP 2017

GAS ASSOCIATION, :

: Appeal from the Order of the

Appellee : Commonwealth Court entered March

: 29, 2017 at No. 1175 CD 2015,

: reversing the Order of the Public Utility

v. : Commission entered June 11, 2015 at

: No. C-2014-2402746.

:

PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY : ARGUED: April 11, 2018

COMMISSION, :

:

Appellant :

CONCURRING OPINION

JUSTICE WECHT DECIDED: DECEMBER 28, 2018

I join in today’s result, which the learned Majority reaches by way of an exemplary

analysis and opinion. Elsewhere, I have discussed the maddening complexities that can

arise when we are called upon to construe the short yet elusive term “any.” See

Commonwealth v. Ricker, 170 A.3d 494, 510-13 (Wecht, J., dissenting). Because “any”

is manifestly ambiguous as codified in the definition of “Stripper well” provided at Section

2301 of Act 13,1 we must resort to our familiar enterprise of statutory interpretation.

The Majority faithfully recites and applies several factors listed in the Statutory

Construction Act2 as guides for ascertaining legislative intent when the General

Assembly’s words “are not explicit.” 1 Pa.C.S. § 1921(c). As part of that analysis, the

Majority performs a close and careful reading of the relevant statutory provisions within

the context of the “statutory structure,” Maj. Op. at 30, 32-33, and “the overall legislative

design,” id. at 34-36. As the Majority astutely recognizes, Act 13 is designed to provide

relief to municipalities impacted by unconventional wells. Id. at 32-33.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.