United States Court of Federal Claims December 28, 2018, 18-496 (Stahl v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-2018

lln tbB Glnrte! $tutls @ourt of fre\ersl @lstms

No. 18-496C

Filed: December 27 ,2018

*,t rr * rr * * * * * *,f * * * * + *****+********** r. ** :f ** *

CHRISTINE E. STAHL,

Plarntiff, pro se,

THE TINITED STATES,

Defendant.

****+*************++*******:t**+*********

Christine E. Stahl, Tampa, Florida, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sonia Williams Murphy, United States Department of Justice, Civil Division, Washington, D.C.,

Counsel for the Government.

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND

DENYING IN PART THE GOVERNMENT'S MOTION TO DISMISS

BRADEN, Senior Judge.

I. RELEVANT F'ACTUAL BACKGROUND.I

Dr. Christine E. Stahl was an active duty United States Air Force ("Air Force") Lieutenant

Colonel ("Lt. Col."), who served for approximately 17 years and 9.5 months, most recently as the

Medical Director of the Intemal Medicine Clinic of the 6n Medical Operations Squadron at

MacDill Air Force Base ("MacDill") in Tampa, Florida. Compl. at 2. From December 18, 2009

to March 1, 2017, Lt. Col. Stahl was stationed at MacDill, but for a one year deployment to

Afghanistan in2012. Compl. at 2-3.

In October of 2013, Lt. Col. Stahl entered into an agreement with the Air Force to accept

$20,000 in Multi-Year Incentive Special Pay C'MISP') and $35,000 in Multi-Year Special Pay

('MSP'), in exchange for a four year active duty service commitment ('ADSC'). Compl. at 3.

This required Lt. Col. Stahl to serve until November 30, 2017, subject to pro rata recoupment of

the MISP and MSP, if she did not serve for the entire term. Compl. at 3.

I The facts

herein were derived fiom the April 4, 2018 Transfer Complaint ("Compl.").

In January 2014, Lt. Col. Stahl "suffered hardship" caused by her mother's death and a

divorce proceeding that resulted in shared custody of her two children' Compl at 3 '

In December 2015, Lt. Col. Stahl was selected for promotion to colonel, with an expected

promotion date of May 2017 . Compl. at 4.

on March 15. 2016.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.