California Court of Appeal, 5th District August 2, 2018, C084870 (Jones v. Sorenson)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-2018

Duarte, J.

*936Despite the prevalence of "do-it-yourself" manuals and television shows, most homeowners eventually decide that some home repairs or maintenance would best be done by hiring someone to do the work. Inevitably, some workers are injured. There are sometimes confusing rules about when a homeowner is liable for injuries to workers on the property, either in tort or under the workers' compensation system. The common questions include whether the person hired by the homeowner was (1) required to be a licensed professional to do the work, and (2) if so, whether the person had the required license.

As stated by our Supreme Court, "It is doubtful the average homeowner realizes tree trimming can require a contractor's license." ( Fernandez v. Lawson (2003) 31 Cal.4th 31, 37, 1 Cal.Rptr.3d 422, 71 P.3d 779 ( Fernandez ).)

Plaintiff Mary E. Jones appeals from a judgment after a grant of summary judgment to defendant Danita Sorenson. Sorenson hired a gardener to work on her property and the gardener hired Jones to help her. Jones was injured when she fell from a ladder while trimming a tree at least 15 feet tall. Jones sued Sorenson, claiming such work required a license but the gardener was not licensed and the gardener's negligence caused the fall. Jones claimed that Sorenson was liable to Jones under a respondeat superior theory, because she was as a matter of law the employer of both the gardener and Jones.

The trial court ruled in effect that the terms "gardener" and "nurseryperson" as used in *274Business and Professions Code section 7026.11 were synonymous, and therefore Sorenson could avoid tort liability *937because a person acting as a nurseryperson may trim trees 15 feet tall or higher without a contractor's license, although a gardener cannot.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.