California Court of Appeal, 5th District September 25, 2018, A144214 (People ex rel. Becerra v. Huber)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-09-2018

Streeter, Acting P.J.

I. INTRODUCTION

This appeal is from a summary adjudication order and permanent injunction entered in an enforcement action by the Attorney General on behalf of the People of the State of California against Ardith Huber, a member of the Wiyot Band of Indians. Huber owns and operates a tobacco smokeshop on the Table Bluff Rancheria, an area where the Wiyots live just outside of Crescent City, in Humboldt County.

The Attorney General's complaint alleges a claim for violation of the Unfair Competition Law, Business and Professions Code section 17200 et seq uitur (the UCL) and cites as predicate "unlawful acts" violations of three statutes applicable to cigarette sales and marketing, the Tax Stamp Act ( Rev. & Tax. Code, § 30161 ), the Directory Act ( Rev. & Tax. Code, § 30165.1, subd. (e)(2) ), and the Fire Safety Act ( Health & Saf. Code, § 14951, subd. (a) ). He also pleads, as separate claims, violations of the Directory Act and the Fire Safety Act. The trial court granted summary adjudication to the to the People, denied it to Huber, and entered a permanent injunction on all three claims.

Huber's primary argument on appeal is an attack on subject matter jurisdiction. She contends that, under a federal statute granting California courts plenary criminal jurisdiction but limited civil jurisdiction over cases arising on Indian reservations, the trial court lacked power to proceed on any of the three claims in this case. She also argues that, under the doctrine of Indian preemption, which limits the reach of state law to conduct by Indians on Indian reservations, all the statutes the Attorney General seeks to enforce here are preempted by paramount federal authority.

We reverse in part, agreeing the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction to proceed on the UCL claim, but in all other respects affirm.

II. BACKGROUND

A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.