Court of Appeals of Texas June 8, 2018, NO. 03-16-00303-CV (Lockheed Martin Corp. v. Hegar)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-06-2018
Bob Pemberton, Justice
This appeal arises at a first-impression intersection between our State's franchise-tax law and the federal laws that restrict the export of military articles from the United States to foreign nations. The pivotal issue concerns the proper "sourcing," for Texas franchise-tax-apportionment purposes, of receipts from Lockheed Martin Corporation's sales of fighter aircraft through "Foreign Military Sales" (FMS) transactions. FMS transactions, simply described, and as relevant here, entail the United States government's procurement from a domestic contractor of defense articles for resale to, and ultimate use by, the *857military forces of a foreign government. The Comptroller insists that Lockheed Martin's revenues from these FMS transactions are Texas receipts (and, therefore, serve ultimately to increase the company's Texas franchise-tax liability) because of certain U.S. government actions that occurred here. Lockheed Martin urges that the receipts are instead properly sourced to the respective foreign nations of the aircraft's ultimate users. The district court agreed with the Comptroller, and hence this appeal by Lockheed Martin. We will affirm the district court's judgment.
THE FMS TRANSACTIONS
The federal legal landscape that forms the context of the parties' Texas tax dispute begins with the Arms Export Control Act (AECA), which restricts sales of U.S.-made military goods and services to foreign nations so as to ensure consistency with U.S. foreign-policy and strategic interests.1 There are two primary means under the AECA by which such sales can be authorized. First, under what is known as a "Direct Commercial Sales" (DCS) transaction, approved foreign governments may negotiate and contract directly to purchase certain military goods and services from a U.S. contractor that obtains an export license issued by the State Department.2 The second means is the "Foreign Military Sales" or "FMS" transaction or program, our immediate focus here.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit