Missouri Court of Appeals June 26, 2018, No. ED 105782 (Farber v. Metro. Police Dep't of St. Louis)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-2018

FOR APPELLANT: Anthony Edward Rothert, Jessica Mary Steffan, 906 Olive Street, Suite 1130, St. Louis, Missouri 63101, Gillian R. Wilcox, 406 West 34th Street, Suite 420, Kansas City, Missouri 64111.

FOR RESPONDENT: Erin Kathleen McGowan, 1200 Market Street, City Hall, Room 314, St. Louis, Missouri 63103.

James M. Dowd, Chief Judge *72This Sunshine Law case arose out of a March 18, 2013 citizen complaint Filed by Curtis Farber against the Metropolitan Police Department of the City of St. Louis (Police Department). Faber's complaint accused several police officers of criminal misconduct-specifically, that they assaulted and threatened to falsify evidence against him-during his arrest on July 9, 2011 for offenses he later pleaded guilty to and for which he received probation. The Internal Affairs Division of the Police Department (IAD) completed its internal investigation of Farber's complaint in September 2013 and notified him in February 2015 of the IAD's finding that his complaint was "not sustained," meaning it was neither proved nor disproved. The Police Department took no further action with respect to Farber's complaint.

On November 3, 2015, Farber made a formal Sunshine Law1 request that the Police Department release to him an un-redacted copy of the IAD report relating to his complaint. At that time, Farber possessed copies only of his initial complaint and the employee misconduct report (EMR) relating to his allegations. The IAD report was not issued to Farber so he sent another request in March 2016, The Police Department denied Farber's request in April 2016 notifying him that the IAD report was a "closed" record. Farber then filed this lawsuit seeking the disclosure of all records from the IAD investigation. On June 10, 2016, the Police Department provided Farber with another copy of the EMR but did not provide him with any of the other records he requested.

The case proceeded to a bench trial in February 2017.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.