Massachusetts Appeals Court March 12, 2018, 16–P–1687 (Commonwealth v. Germaini)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-2018

A Superior Court jury convicted the defendant, Todd J. Germaini, of larceny over $250. Following the conviction, the defendant was found guilty of being a common and notorious thief after a jury-waived trial. On appeal, the defendant contends the denials of his motion for new trial and motion to dismiss were erroneous and his trial counsel was ineffective.2 We affirm.

Background. Based on the evidence presented by the Commonwealth, the jury could have found the following facts. On March 8, 2014, Germaini was in the Hyannis Home Depot store where he was observed by Travis Riggle, the loss prevention employee for Home Depot, taking a "heavy duty" drill and a drill bit from the hardware department. Germaini took the items to the kitchen and bath section of the store where he removed the drill and drill bit from their packaging and put the items down the front of his pants. Germaini then "paced the aisle" at which point he observed Riggle. Upon seeing Riggle, Germaini removed the drill and drill bit from his pants, left them in the kitchen and bath section, and left the store. Riggle stopped Germaini, brought him back into the store, and contacted the Barnstable police. Germaini was placed under arrest and transported to the police station.

Discussion. 1. Motion for new trial. Prior to trial, the defendant was provided with a report of the incident prepared by Riggle. This report incorrectly indicated that the defendant walked out of the store with the items. At trial all parties learned for the first time that the report was incorrect and that Riggle had prepared an amended report that had not been provided to the police or the prosecutor. The defendant's motion for new trial claims that he was prejudiced by the prosecutor's failure to provide him with a copy of Riggle's amended report prior to trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.