Massachusetts Appeals Court May 21, 2018, 16–P–1122 (Commonwealth v. Qadir)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-05-2018
Following a jury trial in the District Court, the defendant, Yusuf Ibn Qadir, was convicted of possession of a firearm without a license, possession of ammunition without a license, and unlawful storage of a firearm. On appeal the defendant challenges the denials of both his motion to suppress and his motion for required findings of not guilty. We affirm.
1. Motion to suppress. a. Facts. We summarize the facts found by the motion judge after the evidentiary hearing. "[W]e are bound by a judge's subsidiary findings of fact absent clear error." Commonwealth v. Clark, 65 Mass. App. Ct. 39, 43 (2005). The judge specifically credited the testimony of the four Springfield police officers who testified at the hearing.
On July 1, 2015, Springfield police officers were dispatched to a residence based on a report of a fight there, involving seven or eight people. As he approached, Officer Chad Joseph observed people running through the front door of the residence and also saw neighbors pointing towards the residence. Joseph was familiar with the location based on a number of prior incidents involving drug violations and domestic abuse.
In front of the residence, Joseph observed a woman who was bleeding from the mouth. Joseph spoke to her and noticed that she was shaking, frantic, and her speech was difficult to understand. She stated that "they beat me up" and pointed to the residence. At this time, backup had arrived, and at least four officers approached the residence. As they stood outside the residence, the officers could hear people running upstairs. The officers knocked on the front door and when it was opened, the officers stated their intention to enter the home and conduct a protective sweep; they did not seek nor were they given consent to enter.
Several officers then entered the residence and proceeded to conduct a protective sweep of the entire house in search of other injured parties or assailants. Joseph went to the second floor with Officers Williams and Dyer.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit