Massachusetts Appeals Court May 18, 2018, 17–P–1001 (Paulini Loam, LLC v. Colbea Enters., LLC)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-05-2018
Paulini Loam, LLC (Paulini) brought suit against abutting landowner Colbea Enterprises, LLC (Colbea)3 and Colbea's tenant, Suburban Shell Service, Inc. (Suburban), seeking removal of certain encroachments on Paulini's land. After a bench trial, a Superior Court judge ordered the defendants to remove some of the encroachments,4 but declined to order the removal of a car-wash structure and a small portion of pavement. As to the car wash, the judge ruled that the encroachment was innocent and de minimis and that requiring removal would be oppressive and inequitable to the defendants while not necessary to protect Paulini's substantial rights. As to the pavement, the judge ruled that Suburban had acquired a prescriptive easement. The parties cross-appeal.
Paulini's appeal. Paulini argues that the judge erred by not ordering the defendants to remove the car wash. We review the judge's findings of fact for clear error and his conclusions of law de novo. See Cavadi v. DeYeso, 458 Mass. 615, 624 (2011). "We examine the judge's imposition of equitable remedies under an abuse of discretion standard." Ibid., quoting from Demoulas v. Demoulas, 428 Mass. 555, 589 (1998).
The judge's reasons for not ordering removal were sound. First, he was warranted in concluding that the encroachment was innocent based on evidence that Colbea's predecessor in title had the land surveyed before building the car wash in 1997. Paulini raises no serious challenge to the factual support for the judge's determination. Instead, Paulini argues that, even if the original encroachment was innocent, Colbea cannot claim innocence because it purchased the property in the middle of litigation and thus with knowledge of the encroachment. But Paulini cites no authority to support the proposition that an encroachment, made innocently, loses its innocence upon sale of the property.5 Paulini's conclusory claim does not rise to the level of adequate appellate argument. See Mass.R.A.P.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit