District Court, D. Nevada March 27, 2018, Case No.: 2:16-cv-00730-JAD-PAL (Patel v. Dennett)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-03-2018
Jennifer A. Dorsey, U.S. District Judge
Sagar Navin Patel sues Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Officer Boe Dennett for excessive force and free-speech violations arising out of an altercation on Paradise Boulevard in Las Vegas. Dennett moves for summary judgment. Because there are genuine disputes of material fact about whether Dennett used excessive force in response to Patel's exercise of his free-speech rights, and because Dennett is not entitled to qualified immunity, I deny the motion.
Background
On April 4, 2014, Patel, an Indian-American man, traveled to Las Vegas with several of his family members for a bachelor party.1 The next day, they watched some basketball games, ate lunch around noon, visited casinos on the Strip, and eventually headed to a strip club. Patel consumed alcohol throughout the day. At around midnight, the group left the strip club and walked down Paradise Boulevard in search of dinner. They contemplated a Japanese restaurant, decided they wanted something else, and continued down Paradise toward some advertising lights they saw in the distance. Frustrated with the lack of options, Patel, who was walking 15- 20 feet behind his friends, shouted to them, "is there any fucking place to eat around this place?"2 From their patrol car, Dennett and his partner, Joseph Smith, heard Patel *891yelling obscenities.3 At this point, Dennett's and Patel's accounts of what happened diverge considerably.
A. Dennett's account
Dennett testified that he and Smith first observed Patel yelling obscenities and attempting to enter a closed business.4 Officer Maile Hanks, who had been driving a patrol car behind Dennett, also noticed Patel walking behind his group shouting obscenities.5 Dennett saw Patel's cousins attempt to coax him along, but Patel responded by yelling profanities at them and telling them to back off.6
Dennett rolled down the passenger-side window of Smith's patrol car and told Patel to go home.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit