Court of Appeals of Wisconsin December 11, 2018, Appeal No. 2017AP1443 (Siddique v. Bd. of Regents Univ. of Wis. Sys.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-2018

DUGAN, J.

¶1 M. Samir Siddique appeals an order denying his motion for costs and attorney fees under the Wisconsin Equal Access to Justice Act (WEAJA), WIS. STAT. § 814.245 (2015-16).1

¶2 This case arises from Siddique's conduct in the wake of a University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee (UWM) student government election in 2013 and sanctions that were imposed upon him for that conduct. Siddique appealed the imposition of the sanctions and when his appeals were denied, he commenced this action against the Board of Regents University Wisconsin System (the Board) and individuals associated with UWM in the Milwaukee County Circuit Court alleging three causes of action: (1) judicial review of the administrative decision imposing the sanctions; (2) civil rights violations; and (3) public records violations. While the action was pending, UWM voluntarily voided the sanctions and the action was dismissed as moot. Siddique challenges the trial court's determinations that pursuant to the WEAJA he was not a prevailing party and that the Board was substantially justified in taking its position.

¶3 We conclude that because Siddique was not a prevailing party under the WEAJA he was not entitled to an award of fees under that statute. Therefore, we affirm.

BACKGROUND

¶4 In 2013, Siddique initially ran for president of the "Student Association at UWM," the student government recognized by UWM. However, prior to the election, he withdrew his candidacy because he had reached an agreement with another student presidential candidate to withdraw, in exchange for a promised appointed position within the Student Association.2

¶5 After becoming aware of issues with the 2013 elections, the Chancellor at the time decided that UWM would not recognize the election result. Subsequent elections were held in 2014, but Siddique did not run for office. Instead, he refused to accept the legitimacy of the student government elected in 2014 and created an organization called the "UWM Student Association.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.