District Court, N.D. Ohio September 17, 2019, 1:18-cv-02162 (Little v. Commissioner of Social Security)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-2019

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

EASTERN DIVISION

ROBIN LITTLE o/b/o A.J.L., ) CASE NO. 1:18cv2162

)

Plaintiff, ) MAGISTRATE JUDGE

) WILLIAM H. BAUGHMAN, JR.

v. )

)

COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL )

SECURITY, )

) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND

Defendant. ORDER

Introduction

Robin Little, on behalf of her child, sought child’s supplemental security income

benefits because of multiple severe mental impairments. The Commissioner found that

these impairments did not cause limitations sufficiently serious to support a finding of

disability. This decision lacks the support of substantial evidence in the record. I,

therefore, reverse the decision and remand for further consideration.1

Analysis

The oral argument brought the following issue into focus:

• In this child’s supplemental security income case, the ALJ found that the

plaintiff had a marked limitation in the interacting and relating to others

domain but a less than marked limitation in the attending and completing

tasks domain. The ALJ used substantially similar evidence and reasoning

as to each finding, highlighting behavioral problems but noting

improvement with treatment. Does substantial evidence support these

findings?

1 The parties have consented to my jurisdiction. ECF #12.

To support a finding of disability in a child’s supplemental security income claim,

on the ground of functional equivalency to a listing, the ALJ must determine that the child

had a marked limitation in two of six domains.2 In this case, the ALJ found that the

plaintiff had a marked limitation in the interacting and relating to others domain.3 As to

the other five domains, the ALJ determined that plaintiff had no limitations or less than

marked limitations.4

The parties agree that the ALJ’s articulation in support of her findings contains

shortcomings. In particular, more than half of the articulation under the two relevant

domains is substantially similar, citing the same medical records.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.