District Court of Appeal of Florida May 6, 2019, 18-1053 (Philip Morris USA Inc. v. Veda Bryant, Personal Representative of the Estate of Johnny Lee Bryant R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-2019

FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL

STATE OF FLORIDA

_____________________________

No. 1D18-1053

_____________________________

PHILIP MORRIS USA INC.,

Appellant,

v.

VEDA BRYANT, Personal

Representative of the Estate of

Johnny Lee Bryant; R.J.

REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY,

Appellees.

_____________________________

On appeal from the Circuit Court for Escambia County.

W. Joel Boles, Judge.

May 6, 2019

WINSOR, J.

Veda Bryant won a $681,000 judgment against Philip Morris

USA Inc. based on her late husband’s addiction to—and injuries

from—smoking cigarettes. Philip Morris now appeals, arguing

that it is entitled to a new trial because plaintiff’s counsel asked

an improper question and made an improper comment during

closing argument. Philip Morris also argues, in the alternative,

that a 2001 stipulation in the original Engle 1 litigation requires a

reduction of the punitive damages award.

First, we agree with Philip Morris and the trial court that

Bryant’s counsel asked an improper question in front of the jury.

As Bryant’s counsel was presenting expert testimony about the

history of tobacco production and consumption, counsel asked the

expert to translate the slogan “veni, vidi, vici,” which had appeared

on packages of Marlboro cigarettes. The expert testified that “[i]t’s

Latin. I came, I saw, I conquered.” 2 Counsel then followed with this

question: “[B]ased on the market sales that we’ve seen in terms of

Philip Morris’ earnings over the years, and the 40-some year

conspiracy, did Marlboro come, see and conquer?” The court

promptly sustained Philip Morris’s objection before the expert

could respond.

The trial court recognized that counsel’s question was an

improper one, and it would be hard to argue otherwise. But the

question we face was whether the trial court was obligated to grant

Philip Morris’s motion for mistrial. We review the court’s ruling

only for an abuse of discretion, Anderson v. State, 841 So. 2d 390,

403 (Fla.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.