District Court of Appeal of Florida May 29, 2019, 17-4469 (CLEMENTE ARIAS v. MARY ANNA PORTER)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-2019

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE REHEARING

MOTION AND, IF FILED, DETERMINED

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL

OF FLORIDA

SECOND DISTRICT

CLEMENTE ARIAS, )

)

Appellant, )

)

v. ) Case No. 2D17-4469

)

MARY ANNA PORTER; ANGELIQUE )

FLORES; and AMARILYS ARIAS, )

)

Appellees. )

)

Opinion filed May 29, 2019.

Appeal from the Circuit Court for

Hillsborough County; Elizabeth G. Rice,

Judge.

Kathryn E. Lee and Kevin Britt Woods of

Woods Trial Law, Tampa, for Appellant.

Ezequiel Lugo of Banker Lopez Gassler

P.A., Tampa, for Appellees Mary Anna

Porter and Angelique Flores.

No appearance for remaining Appellee.

SALARIO, Judge.

In this personal injury action against Mary Anna Porter and Angelique

Flores arising from an automobile accident, a jury awarded Clemente Arias damages for

past and future medical expenses but no past or future noneconomic damages, which

here were argued to consist principally of pain and suffering. Mr. Arias appeals from

that judgment and challenges an order of the trial court denying his motion for additur

on grounds that the jury's zero verdict on noneconomic damages—both past and

future—was inadequate. We reverse the zero verdict for past noneconomic damages

because, under our court's precedents, that verdict was inadequate as a matter of law.

We affirm as to future pain and suffering, however, because the trial court was within its

discretion to conclude that the jury fairly resolved that question against Mr. Arias based

on the disputed evidence at the trial.

I.

The accident and lawsuit. After a trip to the grocery store with his

daughter, Mr. Arias stopped the car that he was driving at a red light. At the same time,

Ms. Flores, who was driving a pickup truck owned by Ms. Porter, made an illegal left

turn into the intersection. Ms. Flores hit another car that was in the intersection, which

caused that car to hit the one Mr. Arias was driving. Mr. Arias did not receive medical

treatment at the scene. Nor did he go to the hospital after the accident.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.