Court of Appeals of Tennessee September 9, 2019, M2018-01977-COA-R3-CV (In Re Estate of John E. Mayfield - Dissenting)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-09-2019

09/09/2019

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

AT NASHVILLE

June 4, 2019 Session

IN RE ESTATE OF JOHN E. MAYFIELD

Appeal from the Chancery Court for Cheatham County

No. P-2880 Suzanne Lockert-Mash, Judge

No. M2018-01977-COA-R3-CV

D. MICHAEL SWINEY, C.J., dissenting.

I respectfully dissent from the majority’s reversal of the Trial Court’s order

dismissing Mr. Saltsman’s claim. I instead would affirm the dismissal because Mr.

Mayfield informed Mr. Saltsman before Mr. Saltsman ever even saw it that the

Commercial Purchase and Sale Agreement (“the Purported Instrument”) was invalid and,

as the majority states, “had to be rewritten . . .”, and Mr. Saltsman acknowledged and

agreed to that.

It is well-recognized that a lawyer is a client’s agent. World Relief Corp. of Nat’l

Ass’n of Evangelicals v. Messay, No. M2005-01533-COA-R3-CV, 2007 WL 2198199, at

*5 (Tenn. Ct. App. July 26, 2007), no appl. perm. appeal filed. Someone in Mr.

Mayfield’s attorney’s office where the document had been drafted alerted Ms. Clayton,

who in turn informed Mr. Saltsman, that the Purported Instrument was invalid and would

have to be rewritten. As to how those events unfolded, the Trial Court found Ms.

Clayton’s testimony more credible than Mr. Saltsman’s as to her informing Mr. Saltsman

of the document’s invalidity and his response. The record is silent as to what the problem

was with the Purported Instrument to render it invalid. That, however, does not matter.

When Mr. Mayfield’s attorney informed Mr. Saltsman through Ms. Clayton before Mr.

Saltsman even saw it that the Purported Instrument was “the wrong contract” and would

have to be rewritten, it was as though Mr. Mayfield himself had torn it up before Mr.

Saltsman saw it. Mr. Saltsman then both acknowledged and agreed to the repudiation of

the document, not of their agreement whatever it was, but only this document. Mr.

Saltsman even proposed a new term—that his company rather than him personally be

named as the buyer in the new document.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.