Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel February 4, 2019 (Mandatory Disclosure of Civil Rights Cold Case Records)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-2019

(Slip Opinion)

Mandatory Disclosure of Civil Rights Cold Case Records

The mandatory disclosure regime in S. 3191, the Civil Rights Cold Case Records Collec-

tion Act of 2018, could curtail the President’s ability to protect information subject to

executive privilege.

S. 3191 unconstitutionality restricts the qualifications for appointees to the Civil Rights

Cold Case Records Review Board and unconstitutionally dictates the timing of their

appointments.

S. 3191 unconstitutionally restricts the President’s supervision of th e Executive Branch

by prohibiting the President from removing Review Board members absent cause.

February 4, 2019

MEMORANDUM OPINION FOR THE

DEPUTY COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT

On December 27, 2018, Congress presented S. 3191, the Civil Rights

Cold Case Records Collection Act of 2018, to the President as an en-

rolled bill. Relying on advice from this Office, the Department of Justice

had raised serious constitutional concerns about earlier versions of this

bill.1 Congress alleviated some of those concerns, but major issues re-

mained in the enrolled version. When confronted with legislation pre-

senting similar problems, Presidents have historically issued signing

statements to explain why the Executive believes certain provisions

would violate the Constitution and how the President would interpret or

implement provisions to avoid constitutional infirmities. Consistent with

this Office’s advice, when the President signed this bill into law on

January 8, 2019, he issued a signing statement indicating how the Ad-

ministration would interpret and apply the Act in a manner consistent

with the Constitution. See Statement by the President (Jan. 8, 2019),

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/statement-by-the-

president-24/ (“2019 Signing Statement”); Civil Rights Cold Case Rec-

1 See Letter for Ron Johnson, Chairman, Committee on Homeland Security and Gov-

ernmental Affairs, U.S. Senate, from Prim F.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.