Court of Appeals of Oregon May 1, 2019, A165655 (Linn Cnty. v. Brown)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-2019

DeVORE, J.

*332In a declaratory judgment action, three counties challenge their obligation to provide their employees paid sick leave as required of many Oregon employers by ORS 653.601 to 653.661. The counties contend that they are excused from the obligation under Article XI, section 15, of the Oregon Constitution, which provides that a local government is not required to comply with a state law that requires a local government to "establish a new program or provide an increased level of service for an existing program" when the state fails to provide adequate funding. The trial court agreed, granted the counties' motion for summary judgment, and entered a judgment that made rulings declaring the paid sick leave law to be an unfunded program. The governor and labor commissioner appeal from that judgment, arguing that the trial court erred in its broad interpretation of Article XI, section 15. We agree, concluding that the paid sick leave law is not an unfunded program of services to others within the meaning of Article XI, section 15. Consequently, the trial court erred in granting the counties' motion and entering a declaratory judgment for the counties. We reverse and remand.1

I. BACKGROUND

A. Trial Court Proceedings

Initially, plaintiffs, then nine Oregon counties, filed a complaint in which they alleged that the paid sick leave law compelled them to spend money on a new program or to spend more money for an existing program without any or enough state reimbursement, in violation of Article XI, section 15.2 They sought a declaratory judgment to that effect and injunctive relief pursuant to ORS 28.020 and ORS 28.080.3 Defendants, the governor *703and labor commissioner, *333responded that the constitutional measure did not apply, adding that, even if the measure applied, all nine counties did not spend more than one-hundredth of one percent of a county's annual budget, which Article XI, subsection 15(3), set as a threshold of applicability.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.