Oregon Supreme Court August 8, 2019, SC S065553 (Caren v. Providence Health Sys. Or. (In re Caren))

Also known as

United States · · · 08-08-2019

FLYNN, J.

**468The dispute in this workers' compensation case arises from the intersection of overlapping statutory provisions that control the determination of a worker's permanent partial disability. ORS 656.214 obligates employers to provide compensation for a worker's permanent impairment, meaning "loss of use or function" that is "due to the compensable industrial injury." ORS 656.214(1)(a). But another statute limits the employer's liability when the compensable injury combines with a qualifying "preexisting condition" to "cause or prolong" the injured worker's' disability or need for medical treatment, unless the compensable injury is the "major contributing *69cause" of the "combined condition."1 ORS 656.005(7)(a)(B). As part of that liability limit, the legislature has created a process by which the employer issues a denial of the "combined condition" and then pays permanent partial disability compensation only for the estimated portion of the worker's permanent impairment that is attributable to the "current accepted condition." ORS 656.268 (1)(b). The question we must resolve is whether the legislature intended that an employer would obtain the same limited liability when the employer has not followed the process that the legislature has created for estimating a reduced amount of permanent impairment following the denial of a "combined condition." We conclude that the legislature intended that injured workers would be fully compensated for new impairment if it is due in material part to the compensable injury, except where an employer has made use of the statutory process for reducing liability after issuing a combined condition denial.

I. BACKGROUND

A. Overview of the Workers' Compensation Claims Process

We begin with an overview of key terminology and the basic workers' compensation claim process before **469explaining the procedural history of this particular case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.