Court of Appeals of North Carolina March 19, 2019, No. COA 18-383 (Helbein v. Helbein)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-03-2019
MURPHY, Judge.
A jury trial was held to determine the validity of a premarital agreement between a husband and wife. The jury found the agreement to be unenforceable, as the wife did not execute the document voluntarily. The husband now appeals the denial of his motions for summary judgment, directed verdict, and new trial. Where a party appeals from interlocutory orders that do not fall within a statutory exception, we dismiss. A trial court does not err in denying a motion for new trial where a jury instruction is supported by evidence. Additionally, a trial court does not err in denying a motion for new trial where opposing counsel's statements made before the jury without objection are not grossly improper. Accordingly, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
Lauren Helbein ("Lauren") worked in the accounts receivable department at a scrap metal brokerage firm in 1986 when she met Isaac Robert Helbein ("Bobby"), an employee of his family's scrap metal business, Southern Metals Company, Inc. After speaking on the phone professionally, Lauren and Bobby eventually met in person and began a romantic relationship. A few years later, the couple became engaged and were wed on 6 October 1995. While both parties agreed that a Premarital Agreement was executed prior to the wedding, the events of the days leading up to the wedding remain disputed.
According to Lauren, she and Bobby first discussed the idea of a premarital agreement two to three days before the wedding. She testified that Bobby told her that "he wanted to make sure that the business would be left to his son." Lauren agreed, but wanted to be sure that "anything that [she and Bobby] built together would be [theirs] and would be shared." Lauren testified that Bobby agreed to her request, and the two did not discuss the details of the premarital agreement until the day of the wedding. On that day, approximately one hour before the wedding, Lauren stated that Bobby took her to his lawyer's office to sign a "Prenuptial Agreement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit