District Court of Appeal of Florida March 22, 2019, Case No. 5D17-4041 (State v. Phillips)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-03-2019

EISNAUGLE, J.

The State of Florida appeals an order suppressing evidence obtained from a probationary search of Appellee's, Mark Leroy Phillips, Sr., cell phones, arguing that the search was reasonable pursuant to the Fourth Amendment. We agree and conclude that the search was reasonable because the government's interest in supervising Appellee while he was on probation for sex offenses against a child outweighed Appellee's privacy interest in his cell phone data. We therefore reverse the order of suppression.

The Probationary Search in this Case

In 1994, Appellee pled guilty to attempted sexual battery on a child, lewd and lascivious conduct upon a child, and sexual activity with a child by a person in familial or custodial authority. He was sentenced to ten years in prison followed by fifteen years of probation. The express terms of Appellee's probation included:

The Court retains custody over your person and authorizes any officer to search you at any time and search all vehicles and premises concerning which you have legal standing to give consent to search.

No contact with minor children without supervision of [an] adult.

You will promptly and truthfully answer all inquiries directed to you by the Court or Community Control/Probation Officer and allow the Officer to visit in your home, at your employment site or elsewhere ....

Although Appellee's terms of probation were expansive, they did not include an express authorization to search Appellee's cell phone data.1

After his release from prison, and while he was registered as a sexual offender, Appellee's probation officer visited his home and conducted a forensic download of his cell phones. The officer did not have a warrant to search electronic devices, nor did she have reasonable suspicion to believe Appellee had violated his probation or otherwise committed any crime.

A search of the cell phones' data revealed two online identifiers that Appellee had allegedly failed to report in violation of section 943.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.