District Court, E.D. New York March 25, 2019, 18-CV-2207(JS) (Patrusky v. Jungle Treats, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-03-2019

SEYBERT, District Judge:

*203Before the Court is an appeal filed by Robin A. Patrusky ("Patrusky" or "Appellant") from Judge Alan S. Trust's April 13, 2018 order (the "Order") denying Patrusky's motion to avoid Jungle Treats, Inc.'s ("Jungle Treats" or "Appellee") judicial lien in the principal amount of $ 480,364.80 in Patrusky's Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Proceeding (Bankruptcy No. 16-75552). For the reasons that follow, the Order is AFFIRMED and this appeal is DENIED.

BACKGROUND

I. Factual Background 1

Patrusky owned a candy company called Nutritious Creations, Ltd. ("Nutritious"). In 2008, she entered into an agreement with Jungle Treats to manufacture nut bars. When the parties' business relationship ended, Jungle Treats commenced a New York State Court action against Patrusky and Nutritious. Ultimately, Jungle Treats obtained a judgment against both Patrusky and Nutritious. Jungle Treats' $ 480,364.80 judgment lien was entered by the Suffolk County Clerk's Office on May 11, 2015 (the "Lien"). (Lien (D.E. 3 at 93-99) at 98.)

At the time, she lived at 12 Redan Drive, Smithtown, New York ("the Home"), a house she purchased in 2004 for $ 815,000.00. (Obj. to Mot. (D.E. 3 at 103-13) at 105; Appellant's Br., D.E. 4, at 2.) According to Patrusky, as "her business began to fail" and "her income diminished, she recognized the necessity of selling her Homestead and placed [her home] on the market." (Appellant's Br. at 6.) In October 2013 (before the Lien was entered), she transferred the home to her daughter Jessica Cantanzaro and son-in-law Michael Cantanzaro (the "Children") for a sale price of $ 615,000.00 (the "2013 Transfer"), though in September 2013, the house had been appraised at approximately $ 800,000.00. (M. Cantanzaro Dep. (D.E. 3 at 115-25) at 118-120.) The sale price was further reduced by a "gift of equity" of $ 92,250.00 and a seller's concession of $ 24,757.20. (Obj. to Mot. at 106, ¶ 17; M. Cantanzaro Dep. at 123.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.