District Court, N.D. California September 9, 2020, 4:12-cv-03970 (Software Rights Archive, LLC v. Facebook, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-09-2020

1

2

3

4 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

5 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

6

7 SOFTWARE RIGHTS ARCHIVE, LLC, Case No. 12-cv-03970-HSG

8 Plaintiff, ORDER GRANTING FACEBOOK’S

MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE

9 v. PLEADINGS

10 FACEBOOK, INC., Re: Dkt. Nos. 197, 198, 205, 212

11 Defendant.

12 Pending before the Court is Defendant Facebook, Inc.’s (“Facebook”) motion for judgment

13 on the pleadings. Dkt. No. 205 (“Mot.”), 215 (“Opp.”), and 222 (“Reply”). For the reasons

14 explained below, the Court GRANTS the motion.1

15 I. BACKGROUND

16 A. The Patents

17 All three asserted patents, U.S. Patents Nos. 5,544,352 (“’352 Patent”), 5,832,484 (“’494

18 Patent”), and 6,233,571 (“’571 Patent”), share the same title—“Method and Apparatus for

19 Indexing, Searching and Displaying Data”—and generally relate to a research tool for indexing,

20 searching and displaying data that focuses on the relationship between items. See Dkt. No. 198-2

21 (’352 Patent), 198-4 (’494 Patent), 198-6 (’571 Patent). The ’352 Patent is a parent patent of the

22 continuation-in-part ’494 and ’571 Patents. All three share substantially the same written

23 description, with the ’494 and ’571 Patents adding network- or web-related disclosure to the ’352

24 patent. All three specifications identify problems in the then-existing text-based computer search

25

26

1 Because the Court’s reasoning applies to both the asserted claims and the contingent claims

identified in Software Rights Archive, LLC’s (“SRA”) motion for leave to amend claim election

27

and infringement contentions, the Court also DENIES that motion. Dkt. No. 198. The Court

1 technology (Boolean search), which would fail to return a desired result because the request was

2 not precisely phrased, or would produce too many results without any indication as to which result

3 was significant or important. See e.g., ’571 Patent, at col. 1, ll. 54 – col. 2, ll. 13. The patents

4 instead use “non-semantic link analysis (i.e.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.