District Court, S.D. Mississippi February 27, 2020, 5:18-cv-00115 (Hutchins v. Belk, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-2020

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI

WESTERN DIVISION

MATTIE HUTCHINS PLAINTIFF

v. CAUSE NO. 5:18-cv-115-DCB-MTP

BELK STORES OF MISSISSIPPI, LLC

i/i/a BELK, INC.

and DOE DEFENDANTS 1 THROUGH 5 DEFENDANTS

ORDER

This matter is before the Court on a Motion for Partial

Summary Judgment on Punitive Damages [ECF No. 50] filed by

Defendant, Belk, Stores of Mississippi, LLC. i/i/a/ Belk, Inc.

(“Belk”). Counsel for Plaintiff Mattie Hutchins (“Hutchins”) has

informed the Court that she has no objection to dismissal of the

punitive damages count in the Complaint. Having read the Motion,

memorandum in support, applicable statutory and case law, and

being otherwise fully informed in the premises, the Court finds

that the Defendant’s Motion shall be GRANTED.

Background

This is a slip and fall case. On or about November 23,

2015, Hutchins was shopping at the Belk store in Natchez,

Mississippi. [ECF No. 50-1] at 2. After shopping, Plaintiff

slipped while walking towards the register – no one was near her

at the time of her fall. [ECF No. 50-2] at pp. 18-19, 25. When

she tried to get up, she looked down and noted a brown substance

on the floor. Id. at 19. Hutchins claims that she did not see

the substance before she slipped, but that she estimated it was

about the diameter of a water bottle. Id. at 20. Plaintiff

describes the substance as being smeared and looking like melted

chocolate. Id. According to the Plaintiff, Courtney Owens, a

Belk employee at the time, asked Hutchins if she “fell on that

brown stuff around there?” and informed Hutchins that she

[Owens] had “told them to get that stuff off that floor.” Id.

at 26.

Belk has denied that such a substance was on the floor. In

fact, Zerline King, the Belk employee who completed the incident

report that day, reported that she walked the aisle and could

not find anything that Hutchins slipped on. [ECF N0. 50-3] at

16.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.