District Court, D. Montana October 27, 2020, 9:19-cv-00047 (Helena Hunters and Anglers Association v. Marten)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-2020

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA

MISSOULA DIVISION

HELENA HUNTERS AND

ANGLERS ASSOCIATION, and

CV 19–47–M–DLC

MONTANA WILDLIFE

FEDERATION,

(Consolidated with Case No.

CV 19–106–M–DLC)

Plaintiffs, and

ALLIANCE FOR THE WILD

ROCKIES, and NATIVE ORDER

ECOSYSTEM COUNCIL

Consolidated Plaintiffs,

vs.

LEANNE MARTEN, in her official

capacity; UNITED STATES FOREST

SERVICE; UNITED STATES

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,

Federal Defendants, and

STATE OF MONTANA, and

MONTANA BICYCLE GUILD

Defendant-Intervenors

Before the Court is Plaintiffs Alliance for the Wild Rockies, and Native

Ecosystem Council’s (“Alliance”) Motion for Attorney’s Fees and Other Expenses.

(Doc. 114.) This motion is denied as premature.

DISCUSSION

Alliance requests $91,593 in attorney fees and $453.80 in costs under the

Endangered Species Act’s (“ESA”) fee shifting provision or, alternatively, under

the Equal Access to Justice Act (“EAJA”). (Doc. 115 at 5.) Federal Defendants

assert that fees are appropriate under the EAJA and not the ESA. (Doc. 119 at 11.)

They further assert that Alliance’s motion is premature because EAJA fees must be

requested within thirty days of a “final judgment” which has not yet occurred as

this case is on appeal. (Id. at 12.)

The first question is whether Alliance may move for fees under the ESA or

the EAJA. In the underlying litigation, Alliance brought three claims under the

APA and various environmental laws, and only prevailed on its second claim that

the Tenmile Project’s Biological Opinion was inadequately detailed in violation of

the ESA. (Doc. 45 at 2.) Federal Defendants assert that this question is controlled

by Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154, 173–74 (1997), where the Supreme Court

announced that a cause of action against a federal agency based on the

maladministration of the ESA is available only under the APA—which in turn,

gives rise to a fee award under the EAJA. (Id. at 11.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.