District Court, S.D. New York December 9, 2020, 1:20-cv-05945 (Kemper Independence Insurance Company v. Haughey)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-2020

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

---------------------------------------------------------------------- X

:

KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INSURANCE COMPANY, :

:

Plaintiff, :

: 20-CV-5945 (JMF)

-v- :

: MEMORANDUM OPINION

WILLIAM HAUGHEY, : AND ORDER

:

Defendant. :

:

---------------------------------------------------------------------- X

JESSE M. FURMAN, United States District Judge:

As discussed during the telephone conference held yesterday, the parties shall, no later

than January 5, 2021, file a joint letter proposing how the case should proceed, if at all, and

proposing a briefing schedule if appropriate.

Assuming that the parties believe the case should proceed, they should address whether

the Court has jurisdiction to do so in light of the fact that the sole remaining Defendant, William

Haughey, is merely a nominal party. See ECF No. 9. Indeed, upon review of the authorities

cited in Plaintiff’s counsel’s August 5, 2020 letter, it is far from clear that Plaintiff would have a

valid and ripe claim against Mr. Haughey under New York law at this time. Contrary to

counsel’s representations, New York Insurance Law § 3420(a)(2) does not appear to speak to the

issue, let alone provide a cause of action to Plaintiff prior to a judgment in the underlying tort

suit. And as the cases on which counsel relied note, a party is nominal only “if no cause of

action or claim for relief is or could be stated against him or on his behalf as the case may be.”

Lewis Morris Assocs. v. Admiral Ins. Co., No. 04-CV-1757 (SHS), 2004 WL 1065522, at *2

(S.D.N.Y. May 11, 2004) (emphasis added) (internal quotation marks omitted). By definition,

therefore, Plaintiff presumably does not have a valid claim against Mr. Haughey at this time.!

Finally, even if Plaintiff does have a valid claim against Mr. Haughey as a matter of New

York substantive law at this time, ripeness is an independent requirement for federal jurisdiction

under Article III, see, e.g., Herrick Co., Inc. v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.