Court of Special Appeals of Maryland April 1, 2020, 2794/18 (Sayles v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-2020

Karon Sayles v. State of Maryland, No. 2794, Sept. Term, 2018; Dalik Daniel Oxely v.

State of Maryland, No. 2797, Sept. Term 2018, Bobby Jamar Johnson v. State of Maryland,

No. 2798, Sept. Term 2018. Opinion filed on April 1, 2020, by Berger, J.

CRIMINAL LAW – JURY NULLIFICATION

Jury nullification is a jury’s knowing and deliberate rejection of the evidence or refusal to

apply the law either because the jury wants to send a message about some social issue that

is larger than the case itself or because the result dictated by law is contrary to the jury’s

sense of justice, morality, or fairness. The power of juries to nullify is well-established.

CRIMINAL LAW – JURY NULLIFICATION – ARGUMENT TO THE JURY AND

INSTRUCTION BY THE COURT

It is improper for parties to argue nullification to the jury and for the trial court to expressly

instruct the jury that it is permitted to disregard the court’s instructions on the law.

CRIMINAL LAW – JURY NULLIFICATION – RESPONSE TO JURY QUESTION

REGARDING NULLIFICATION

When a trial judge received a question from the jury asking about its power to nullify a

verdict, the trial court committed reversible error when it instructed the jury that

nullification is “contrary to law” and would “violate” a court order. Because a jury’s power

to nullify is well-established, it cannot be said to be “contrary to law.” The trial court’s

instruction that nullification would “violate” a court’s order suggested that jurors could

face legal consequences for engaging in jury nullification, and there is no legal authority

to support such an instruction.

CRIMINAL LAW – JURY NULLIFICATION – RESPONSE TO JURY QUESTION

REGARDING NULLIFICATION – DEFINITION OF JURY NULLIFICATION

When instructing the jury that nullification was “contrary to law,” the trial court defined

jury nullification as “a juror’s knowing and deliberate rejection of the evidence or refusal

to apply the law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.