Court of Appeals of Oregon December 30, 2020, A167087 (Whitehead v. Clarno)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-2020

268

Argued and submitted August 21, 2019, reversed and remanded

December 30, 2020, petition for review allowed May 20, 2021 (368 Or 168)

See later issue Oregon Reports

Richard Taylor WHITEHEAD;

Timothy Grant; and

Citizens in Charge Foundation,

a Virginia not-for-profit corporation,

Plaintiffs-Appellants,

v.

Bev CLARNO,

Secretary of State of the State of Oregon,

Defendant-Respondent.

Marion County Circuit Court

16CV28212; A167087

480 P3d 974

Plaintiffs brought this action under ORS 246.910 to obtain review of a deci-

sion by the Secretary of State, which disqualified Initiative Petition 50 (IP 50)

from the 2016 ballot. The secretary determined that IP 50 lacked a sufficient

number of valid signatures after subtracting the signatures of registered but

“inactive” voters, whom she found were not “qualified voters” for the purposes of

counting signatures on initiative petitions. Plaintiffs sought a declaration under

ORS 28.010 that Article IV, section 1, of the Oregon Constitution grants both

active and inactive registered voters the right to sign initiative petitions and have

their signatures count toward the qualification of those initiatives. The secretary

argued that voters with inactive registrations are not “entitled to vote” and are

therefore not eligible to sign the petitions. The trial court denied summary judg-

ment for plaintiffs and granted the secretary’s motion for summary judgment.

On appeal, plaintiffs argue that a “qualified voter” is entitled to sign initiative

petitions under Article IV, section 1, if he or she meets the requirements of a

“qualified elector” under Article II, section 2, of the Oregon Constitution. And,

because a person may be a “qualified elector” without being actively registered to

vote, that person is qualified to sign an initiative petition. Held: The trial court

erred by granting the secretary’s motion for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.