District Court, S.D. Texas July 10, 2020, 3:20-cv-00012 (In The Matter of the Complaint of Odfjell Chemical Tankers AS, Goldex Fortune Ltd., Odjfell Management AS and Odfjell Tankers AS, as Owners and Operators of the M/T Bow Fortune)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-2020

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT July 10, 2020

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS David J. Bradley, Clerk

GALVESTON DIVISION

ODFJELL CHEMICAL TANKERS §

AS, ET AL., §

§

Plaintiffs, §

§

VS. § CIVIL ACTION NO. 3:20-CV-00012

§

RAYMOND HERRERA, JR., ET AL., §

§

Defendants. §

ORDER

This lawsuit arises from a January 14, 2020 collision between a 600-foot chemical

tanker and a fishing boat in the Galveston Ship Channel. Three men lost their lives in this

tragedy. Another individual was injured. As a result of the accident, multiple wrongful death

and personal injury claims have been asserted against the two vessel owners.

The vessel owners each filed federal actions under the Limitation of Liability Act (the

“Limitation Act”), 46 U.S.C. § 50501 et seq., seeking to limit their liability to the value of

their respective vessels and their freight.1 The two actions are consolidated here.

Pending before me is Claimants’ Motion to Bifurcate (“Motion to Bifurcate”). See

Dkt. 79. In the Motion to Bifurcate, Claimants ask me to ensure that the only issue to be

resolved in the federal forum is the limitation of liability question, allowing Claimants to try

all non-limitation issues in state court. The vessel owners oppose the Motion to Bifurcate,

1 The Odfjell Petitioners are attempting limit their liability to $29,118,136.40. The Master Jimbo

Petitioners are trying to limit their liability to $0.00 since they claim their vessel was worth nothing.

arguing that the limitation of liability and damage issues should be heard in one proceeding

before the district court judge without a jury. Because I find that bifurcation preserves both

the vessel owners’ right to a federal bench trial on the limitation of liability issue and the

Claimants’ right to a state court jury trial on the remaining issues, I GRANT the Motion to

Bifurcate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.